Take a look at our different categories listed below: direct mail leads, internet leads, and prospect lists.

Direct Mail Leads

Dental Direct Mail Lead Program

Dental is a great door-opener to cross-sell your core products, like Medicare Supplement, life insurance, long-term care and annuities. Because dental is cheap and familiar to seniors from their working years, it is a non-threatening product and approach to get you in the door and start a relationship with prospects in your target market.

Kramer Direct

Established in 1985, full-service direct mail campaigns customized for results and compliance. Personalized mailers and gift brochures get you in front of prospects and build your personal brand. Leads are available for Medicare, final expense, long-term care, life, annuities, estate planning, reverse mortgage, dental, health and IRA. See the complete programs here or call toll-free 1-888-572-6373 and ask for your CareValue discount. CMS-compliant Medicare Advantage lead pieces available.

Main Street PowerMAIL

One of the fastest turnaround times for direct mail. Receive your leads as early as 10–14 days after ordering your mailing. If you time it right, you can get your leads and your commissions before you get your credit card bill! Leads are available for Medicare, final expense, annuity and life. Call toll-free 1-866-540-6797 to get counts, more details and to place your order. Be sure to mention you are an CareValue agent in order to receive discount pricing! www.mspowermail.com.


Full-service mail house generating leads for the senior market for over 27 years. TargetLeads offers numerous Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage direct mail pieces with high response rates! Leads are also available for final expense, long-term care, annuities and combo. Leads are not preprinted and can easily be customized for your company’s compliance needs. Visit http://carevalue.targetleads.com/, call toll-free 1-800-723-5254 or email info@targetleads.com for more information or to request a catalog of our various lead mailer samples. Mention you are with CareValue to get special discounted rates!
Image of businesswoman with hand on head with a play button overlay, indicating a video.

Internet Leads

CareValue producers are eligible for steep discounts and free lead credits from these top-rated Internet lead vendors.

Benepath logo.
Exclusive leads only. Leads never re-sold to multiple agents. Leads generated from consumer searches at Google, Bing, and Yahoo. Agent-branded landing pages. Special Offer, get $150 in Aged Leads with a new account setup!
Contact us
HealthPlanOne Logo
Exclusive leads only. Introductory offer for CareValue agents: $75 credit toward first lead purchase!
Contact us

Prospect Lists

Affordable, Accurate and Compliant

Tried and true cold calling of people turning 65 is still allowed for Medicare Supplement (though it is not OK for Medicare Advantage or Part D) so long as they are not on a federal or state Do Not Call List.

Mutual of Omaha USAData

Mutual of Omaha agents have access to low-priced prospect lists (as low as $.04 per name) scrubbed against federal and state Do Not Call Lists. This includes access to the widest selection of filters to pinpoint the best available leads in your area. Easily and securely order and download fresh, privacy-compliant leads online at http://mutualofomaha.usadata.com, or call 1-877-616-6242 to get live expert help and learn what’s helping other agents succeed.
  • Turning 65 prospect lists
  • Extremely competitive rates
  • Guaranteed 94% deliverable
  • Option for phone numbers scrubbed against Do Not Call List
  • Filter by demographics and psychographics
  • Business leads and new homeowner lists also available
Contact us

FREE T-65 Leads:

Insurance agents love our Turning 65 lists for Medicare supplement products.

Partner with CareValue to be eligible for one of the highest ROI in the industry.

Contracted agents can fill out our lead request form and return to Leads@CareValue.com for more information!

Attend a free training webinar ‘How to Get the Most from Your Free Turning 65 Lead List’.
Contact us

Lead Calculator

To measure the success of any business campaign, you must calculate the return on your investment (ROI). Try our free lead calculator below to determine the ROI based on the quantity/price of leads you'd like to work.

AgentCalc Powered by CareValue Logo.

Lead Return on Investment (ROI)

Lead ROI Calculator